Some decisions were easy; some decisions were difficult. Making Roy Hampton the first team quarterback was easy. Deciding which defensive backs with double-digit interceptions to leave off the first team was difficult. Making Dan Pugh a first team running back was easy, but every other running back decision was a struggle.
| First Team | Second Team | |
|
Offense |
||
| QB | Roy Hampton, Sr., Trinity (Texas) | Tom Arth, Sr., John Carroll |
| RB | Dan Pugh, Sr., Mount Union | Fred Jackson, Sr., Coe |
| RB | David Russell, Sr., Linfield | Jeremy Boyce, Sr., Trinity (Texas) |
| WR | Blake Elliott, Sr., St. John's | Mark Boehms, Sr., Alma |
| WR | Jerheme Urban, Sr., Trinity (Texas) | Jeffrey Jourdan, Sr., Hanover |
| TE | Ryan Short, Sr., Wabash | Mike Healy, Jr., Chicago |
| OL | Larry Kinnard, Jr., Mount Union | Jon Spragg, Sr., Wooster |
| OL | J.D. Sheldon, Sr., Augustana | Jeff Hollway, Sr., Ohio Wesleyan |
| OL | Thomas Anderson, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Matt Payne, Sr., John Carroll |
| OL | Ryan Harris, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Bryon Megli, Sr., Aurora |
| OL | Daryl Agpalsa, Sr., Linfield | Ben Knepper, Jr., UW-Stout |
|
Defense |
||
| DL | Steven Wilson, Sr., King's | Pat Ryan, Sr., Benedictine |
| DL | Matt Campbell, Sr., Mount Union | Gerrit Tosh, Sr., Rowan |
| DL | Mike Condello, Sr., Brockport State | Dane Lundgren, Sr., Wheaton |
| DL | Jeremy Hood, Jr., St. John's | Chris Keene, Sr., King's |
| LB | Jamie Spielman, Sr., UW-Stout | Ron Swearingin, Jr., Capital |
| LB | Preston Meyer, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Chris Cubero, Sr., John Carroll |
| LB | Cam McCambridge, Jr., St. John's | Casey Urlacher, Sr., Lake Forest |
| DB | Chris Kern, Sr., Mount Union | Jason Pflipsen, Sr., St. John's |
| DB | Jeff Thomas, Sr., Redlands | David Simpson, Sr., Alma |
| DB | Ray Lions, Jr., Linfield | Evan Zupancic, Sr., Tufts |
| DB | Tyrone Rhone, Sr., UW-Stout | Kory Schramm, Sr., Hartwick |
|
Specialists |
||
| K | Greg Switaj, Jr., Springfield |
Ben Tuck, Sr., Sewanee |
| P | Scott Verhalen, Jr., East Texas Baptist | Sean Lipscomb, Sr., Redlands |
| RET | Blake Elliott, Sr., St. John's | Jeremy Lynch, Jr., Brockport State |
| ST | Scott Farley, Sr., Williams | |
| Third Team | Honorable Mention | |
|
Offense |
||
| QB | Eli Grant, Jr., Case Western | Rob Adamson, Sr., Mount Union |
| RB | David McNeal, Jr., Kings Point | Luke Hagel, Sr., Ripon |
| RB | Randal Baker, Sr., Carthage | Daniel Grove, Sr., Wittenberg |
| WR | Jason Hunt, Sr., Trinity (Texas) | Walter Hays, Jr., Howard Payne |
| WR | Ryan Soule, Sr., Hartwick | Justin Salton, Jr., Franklin & Marshall |
| TE | Matt Moskosky, So., Hardin-Simmons | Jamie Rother, Sr., Brockport State |
| OL | Mat Rapoza, Sr., Washington & Lee | Nerijus Gelazauskas, Sr., W. Connecticut |
| OL | Matthew Atkins, Jr., Thomas More | Ryan Brennan, Sr., Lebanon Valley |
| OL | Bob Fehr, Sr., King's | Jared Carillo, Jr., Trinity (Conn.) |
| OL | James Flowers, Jr., Trinity (Texas) | Charlie Dutra, Jr., Menlo |
| OL | Michael Day, Jr., Bridgewater | Adam Collette, Sr., Tufts |
|
Defense |
||
| DL | Kevin Watson, Sr., Occidental | John Longo, Sr., Cortland State |
| DL | Vince King, Jr., Wartburg | D'Andre Wilson, Sr., Howard Payne |
| DL | Justin Knapp, Sr., Wheaton | Andrew Porter, Sr., Macalester |
| LB | Austin Bonnema, Sr., Central | Casey Carlson, Jr., Pacific Lutheran |
| LB | Josue Zamora, Sr., Westfield State | Matt O'Bryant, Sr., Millsaps |
| LB | Jermaine Taylor, Jr., Bridgewater | Tim Booth, Sr., Hobart |
| LB | Matt Wilchinski, Sr., McDaniel | Casey McConnell, So, Kenyon |
| DB | Nick Hajjar, Sr., Wooster | Kennard Davis, So., Thiel |
| DB | Kyle Hausler, Fr., Capital | Mike Lindhardt, Sr., Westminster (Mo.) |
| DB | Chris Scott, Sr., Hampden-Sydney | Bobby Akers, Sr., Randolph-Macon |
| DB | Nick Carlson, Sr., UW-Oshkosh | Antonio Nash, Sr., Susquehanna |
|
Specialists |
||
| K | Chad Wurth, Jr., UW-Whitewater | Chris Reed, Sr., Muhlenberg |
| P | Mike Donnenwerth, Jr., Simpson | Cory Ohnesorge, Fr., Occidental |
| RET | Shaun Rochon, So., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Roger Snyder, Sr., Washington & Jefferson |