A full season of unfamiliarity

More news about: John Carroll

Nov 25, 2025

Photo by Mike Atherton, d3photography.com

By Greg Thomas
D3football.com

John Carroll didn’t ease its way into the playoffs. The Blue Streaks barreled in with one of the nation’s toughest defenses, the kind of unit built to make playoff games feel a little smaller and opponents feel downright claustrophobic. The Blue Streaks defense ranks in the top 11 in total defense, rushing defense, third down defense, and first downs allowed.

Those numbers read like a team that has become synchronized with the rhythms of a familiar league with familiar personnel and schemes.

Except this was the year nothing was familiar at all.

Their first season in the NCAC meant no shorthand, no shared history, no grudges or tendencies carried over from the last decade. Every Saturday came wrapped in mystery. And for a defense built on structure and communication, that could have felt like a disadvantage.

“The biggest challenge was just not having any familiarity with any of your opponents,” head coach Jeff Behrman said. “You can watch film and get an idea, but not having that experience from league play from previous years does make it difficult.”

Difficult, sure. But also freeing. Instead of leaning on what they thought they knew, the Blue Streaks learned to treat each week as a clean slate. Over time that newness became a kind of superpower, sharpening instincts and forcing a level of attention that turned a talented group into one of Division III’s most complete defenses.

Behrman’s third season at John Carroll could have been a moment of consolidation, a chance to settle into the systems and expectations he’d spent two years installing. What he got instead was a continental shift. The Blue Streaks moved from the OAC where opponents felt like the same familiar playlist on repeat, to the NCAC, where every week dropped a brand new sound entirely.

In the OAC, players inherited decades worth of scouting notes, anecdotes, and “remember when they…” stories. In the NCAC, there was none of that.

“We have such a regimented process in terms of how we go about breaking teams down and game planning,” Behrman said. “We just went through our normal process looking at structures of offenses, defenses, and special teams, looking at the personnel within those structures and looking at strengths and weaknesses.”

What the staff didn’t have was a reference point, and that meant the players didn’t either. Instead of assuming tendencies, they had to absorb everything from scratch.

Senior defensive lineman Tommy Wasinski, an All-NCAC first-teamer, said the staff set the tone early.

“Our coaching staff does a very good job at breaking down film, especially early in the week and communicating with us and being transparent with what to expect and what to look for,” he said. “That makes our practices more intentional and more efficient when we know what to expect, and the communication is elite.”

And the players didn’t just watch what opponents did. Senior linebacker Chris Golson, another first-team All-NCAC selection, found himself studying reactions and body language.

“Whenever we're watching film, for me especially, I like to look and see a little bit after the play, how players react or how they interact with each other,” he said.

This wasn’t just a deep dive on scheme. It was a crash course in reading the entire ecosystem of a new league.

When you don’t know what’s coming, you learn to control what you can. For John Carroll, that meant fundamentals. An old concept, renewed by necessity.

“It’s a completely fresh start and you are able to really focus,” Behrman said. “Sometimes you didn't know what to expect until the ball was kicked on a Saturday because it was all new opponents, new teams, new venues. One thing we always do is focus on our own prep.”

Without years worth of archives to lean on, the Blue Streaks spent more time building a defense based on rules rather than opponent-specific tricks. Players had to adapt to opposing personnel and schemes they’d never seen before. Communication, already a priority, became the defense’s core identity.

“Communication is one of the biggest things we have on our defense,” Golson said. “We have a lot of moving parts, so we have to know what we all have to do together. The last 13 weeks, we’ve come together as a defense and understood how each of us play and the chemistry we have.”

Wasinski added another ingredient: respect. “Coach Paul always says you either respect them now or you respect them later,” he said. “If you do have respect for them before and you play like it and you prepare like it, then your preparation will lead you to success.”

Every week brought a different puzzle. Every week demanded a different answer. By midseason, the defense didn’t just tolerate unfamiliarity; it thrived on it.

If there was a turning point, Behrman saw it in Week 2 against Johns Hopkins. The Blue Streaks gave up 21 points in the first half to one of the nation’s best offenses. But in the second half, the entire unit recalibrated, allowing only two field goals.

Moments like that revealed both the ceiling and the character of this defense. They weren’t perfect, but they were quick to adapt, and that adaptability hardened into confidence.

The variety of offenses they faced in the NCAC only reinforced that. They closed the regular season defending a Denison team that threw 60 times in 65 snaps. This week they’ll see a Randolph-Macon team that runs the ball on nearly three-quarters of its plays. And yet John Carroll’s defense, built in a laboratory of constant change, looks ready for either extreme.

Their national rankings hint at why. The Blue Streaks are second in the nation against the run allowing just 33.3 yards per game which speaks to how quickly they diagnose unfamiliar ground games. Their 11th-ranked third-down defense (allowing just 28.5% conversions) reflects the communication that unlocks situational stops. Ranking fourth nationally in first downs allowed (11.9 per game) shows a team winning early-down battles without needing a deep archive of opponent tendencies.

After three months of new faces and new schemes, adaptability wasn’t just something they did. It was who they were.

Most playoff teams spend the first week adjusting to the curveballs postseason football throws at them: long travel, unfamiliar stadiums, and opponents with entirely new offensive identities. John Carroll already lived that life from Week 1 through Week 11.

“We’re just such creatures of habit,” Behrman said. “I don't know that it’s (playoff preparation) really any different. You’re going to put an opponent in front of us and we're going to start breaking down the film, analyzing how they do things, and devise a plan from there.”

What might feel like a scramble for other teams feels like routine for the Blue Streaks. The NCAC didn’t just prepare them for November; it might have accelerated their readiness for anyone they see beyond it.

Golson believes the mindset they forged is just as important as the scouting routine.

“A big thing for our team has been being unbreakable,” he said. “We’ve had plenty of times where we probably fell short of the things that we really wanted to do. It’s about how do we come back from that, not breaking, being coachable and fixing it on the next play.”

That resilience, and the muscle memory of constant adjustment, travels well in the postseason.

What you know matters in the playoffs, but what you can learn in 48 to 72 hours matters just as much. John Carroll has spent an entire season mastering that skill. Their undefeated run through the NCAC and their first-round playoff bye didn’t come from familiarity; they came from handling unfamiliarity better than anyone else.

Saturday brings Randolph-Macon, another new opponent, another new style, another test of everything they’ve built. And the Blue Streaks, perhaps more than any team in the bracket, know exactly how to handle that.

In a season full of strangers, John Carroll’s defense learned to make every opponent familiar fast. Now in the playoffs, that might be the most valuable thing they know.